McCann, Farrell and Savage v UK (1996) 21 EHRR 97 is one of the leading Strasbourg cases on the ECHR, art 2 and provides guidance on dealing with the situations outlined above. Often known as the 'Death on the Rock' case, it was brought by the relatives of three alleged IRA members who were shot dead in Gibraltar by members of the British security forces. The UK claimed that its agents believed the three suspects were about to detonate a bomb. The court found no violation of the ECHR, art 2 in relation to the shooting by the soldiers themselves. It accepted that the soldiers honestly believed, in the light of the information that they had been given, that it was necessary to shoot the suspects in order to prevent them from causing serious loss of life. The actions which the soldiers took, in obedience to superior orders, were thus [...]. However, the court did find a breach by the UK in relation to the lack of care exercised in the control and organisation of the overall security operation.
Answer
perceived as necessary in order to safeguard innocent lives
Tags
#freedom-of-person #human-rights #public
Question
McCann, Farrell and Savage v UK (1996) 21 EHRR 97 is one of the leading Strasbourg cases on the ECHR, art 2 and provides guidance on dealing with the situations outlined above. Often known as the 'Death on the Rock' case, it was brought by the relatives of three alleged IRA members who were shot dead in Gibraltar by members of the British security forces. The UK claimed that its agents believed the three suspects were about to detonate a bomb. The court found no violation of the ECHR, art 2 in relation to the shooting by the soldiers themselves. It accepted that the soldiers honestly believed, in the light of the information that they had been given, that it was necessary to shoot the suspects in order to prevent them from causing serious loss of life. The actions which the soldiers took, in obedience to superior orders, were thus [...]. However, the court did find a breach by the UK in relation to the lack of care exercised in the control and organisation of the overall security operation.
Answer
?
Tags
#freedom-of-person #human-rights #public
Question
McCann, Farrell and Savage v UK (1996) 21 EHRR 97 is one of the leading Strasbourg cases on the ECHR, art 2 and provides guidance on dealing with the situations outlined above. Often known as the 'Death on the Rock' case, it was brought by the relatives of three alleged IRA members who were shot dead in Gibraltar by members of the British security forces. The UK claimed that its agents believed the three suspects were about to detonate a bomb. The court found no violation of the ECHR, art 2 in relation to the shooting by the soldiers themselves. It accepted that the soldiers honestly believed, in the light of the information that they had been given, that it was necessary to shoot the suspects in order to prevent them from causing serious loss of life. The actions which the soldiers took, in obedience to superior orders, were thus [...]. However, the court did find a breach by the UK in relation to the lack of care exercised in the control and organisation of the overall security operation.
Answer
perceived as necessary in order to safeguard innocent lives
If you want to change selection, open original toplevel document below and click on "Move attachment"
Parent (intermediate) annotation
Open it in the light of the information that they had been given, that it was necessary to shoot the suspects in order to prevent them from causing serious loss of life. The actions which the soldiers took, in obedience to superior orders, were thus <span>perceived as necessary in order to safeguard innocent lives. However, the court did find a breach by the UK in relation to the lack of care exercised in the control and organisation of the overall security operation.<span><body><html>
Original toplevel document (pdf)
cannot see any pdfs
Summary
status
not learned
measured difficulty
37% [default]
last interval [days]
repetition number in this series
0
memorised on
scheduled repetition
scheduled repetition interval
last repetition or drill
Details
No repetitions
Discussion
Do you want to join discussion? Click here to log in or create user.